soviet history reddit

They were pretty passive-aggressive about it though. THE FIGHT OF THE SOVIET UNION FOR PEACE AND COLLECTIVE SECURITY, The rise of disagreements between imperialist countries, The creation of a war source in the Far East, Nazi Germany - the most important source of war, The fight of the Soviet Union for peace and collective security, THE FORMATION OF AN AGGRESSIVE BERLIN-ROME-TOKYO AXIS AND THE STRENGTHENING OF FASCIST AGGRESSION, The Munchen Plot. To hide their plans of invading the USSR. You heard it. Information on the USSR: 1917-1919. Though the terms "Soviet Russia" and "Soviet Union" often are synonymous in everyday speech, when referring to the foundations of the Soviet Union, "Soviet Russia" properly refers to the few years between the October Revolution of 1917 and the creation of the Soviet Union in 1922. That's it. Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket. But the defeat of the Finnish army in 1940 and a peace treaty between the USSR and Finland put an end to the plans of a worldwide imperialist organized coalition war against the Soviet Union. Of course, Gulags where the Soviet people were already slaves are left out of the story. The rest of the book is uninteresting anyway. The ruling classes of France and Britain hoped that Germany will attack the Soviet Union after Poland. Professor Elizabeth Wood, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, will lead the discussion. The Brezhnev period, to be more exact. Furthermore, it offered "to the oppressed toiling masses the opportunity to participate actively in the free construction of a new society". This would make for an interesting alternate history scenario, if you ask me. How Santa Survived the Soviet Era Of all the variations on the beloved character, Russia’s Ded Moroz might have the strangest history. In October of 1936, a deal between Italy and Germany on united action on main questions of foreign policy and dividing Central and Southeast Europe by spheres of influence. Serhii Plokhy is the professor of history and director of the Ukrainian Research Institute at Harvard University. Author should have gone into poetry instead of history. Gorbachev's policy was intended to weaken the hold of the planning in the economy and especially the bureaucracy. Originally Published: July 13, 2018 However the war ended before they could do that. Soviet Russia: A living history, William Henry Chamberlin 1929: One of the least biased and most balanced accounts of the Soviet Union one can find, this author traveled throughout the country interviewing Soviet citizens on various questions. This is the first paragraph of this textbook. In general, this entire section is taking Litvinov's thoughts and putting them as the official stance of the Soviet Union, even though that was far from the case. When you get into things like "Would X would have happened without Y, or if X happened how would that have affected Y?" The Soviet Union is still collapsing. The history of Russia between 1922 and 1991 is essentially the history of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, or Soviet Union. Archie Brown Contemporary Russian Politics, Richard Sakwa Russian Politics and Society, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskHistorians community. Once a bustling Soviet military base, it now looks like an eerie post-apocalyptic wasteland. The Khwarezmian Empire was one of the most powerful civilizations at the time in terms of military, economy, culture, science etc. The Soviet submarine force was one of the largest single projects (in terms of funding) for the Soviet defense complex, which was a huge chunk of their GDP. Germany invaded France, sure, but they wanted to keep the US neutral and didn't really have a serious plan for attacking the UK. The ability of the Soviet Government to maintain power was always based on its ability to provide a decent standard of living which in turn depended on economic growth and on the nature of its institutions both of which were under severe pressure during the 1980's. The Kuomintang clique led by Chiang Kai-Shek did not put up resistance to the aggressor. This category has the following 4 subcategories, out of 4 total. This book also stands on the precipice of an epoch changing event: Collectivization. Soviet and East German soldiers. The improvement of already existing machinery was not emphasized as much as the former primarily because it was believed it would slow down economic growth. The man says, “Here I can complain.” —jbrav88, Reddit user. we just don't even think about it that way. Glasnost allowed for alternate centers of political power to coalesce as information detrimental to the states IMAGE was allowed to circulate and people began to talk. The laboratory activities were mentioned in the Mitrokhin archive While many znachki (lapel pins) are miniature pieces of Soviet propaganda, the form is older than the 1917 revolution. It started with the establishment of large car manufacturing plants and reorganisation of the AMO Factory in Moscow in the late 1920s–early 1930s, during the first five-year plan, and continued until the Soviet Union's dissolution in 1991. Never mind that most of the democrats in Europe were in the Allies. The Soviet government knew that Hitler did not cancel his plans of invading the Soviet Union, and his offer was just a standard maneuver by the fascist leadership. The soviet system was described as "a higher type of state" and "a higher form of democracy" which would "arouse the masses of the exploited toilers to the task of making new history." It is in this context, that we must look at the reforms that were started by Alexei Kosygin in 1965 and again in 1973 which stressed upon profitability and sales of enterprise along with maintenance of old equipment and focus on increasing labor productivity. Wallerstein's perspective on this is pretty fascinating. It's an accumulation of decisions that have been made since 1956, and essentially Gorbachev decides that things need to change - but he does want to improve it to save the communist system. (In the link he talks about capitalism, but the idea is generalizable to systems in general.) Glasnost is largely fuelled by the Chernobyl disaster, in which Soviet authorities try to cover up the huge disaster that is the meltdown at the nuclear power station in Chernobyl, which Gorbachev recognises was a huge misstep. Russian history was pressed into providing a heroic past and patriotic symbols, although selectively, for instance praising men as … The fascist countries were the most aggressive. He gains control back, but he's been undermined. This all changed with glasnost. They're not exactly perfect, but they're ticking along. In 1959, the Soviet Planners had set 1972 as the year to surpass the United States in per-capita output. Main menu. There's a lot of really good discussion in this thread that relates to your question. The Soviet Union, officially the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), was a federal socialist state in Northern Eurasia that existed from 1922 to 1991. Immediately after the Nazi attack, the Polish government shamefully fled and escaped, leaving the nation on their own. Now all we need is ethnic cleansing and we'll get the whole Generalplan Ost package. The Portal for Public History Sadly, this page is missing from my book, so I can't present it to you. The workers were losing their fear in the system because of the weakening of administrative control. I don't even know why. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. 28 notes Feb 15th, 2019. We have basically everything you need for a written Soviet era experience - the entire Great Soviet Encyclopedia, dozens of books about state atheism, CPSU leaders and history, Russian literature, and a whole batch of history textbooks from the Soviet period. He had to allow the collapse of the Soviet-installed governments in Eastern Europe because of Soviet dependence on foreign imports and consequent Western leverage. and was wiped off the face of the Earth in a couple short years by Genghis Khan. Skip to primary content. The fight of imperialist murderers was especially tense due to the inequalities between capitalist nations. It's the unravelling of Gorbachev's reforms, undermined by glasnost and the loss of controlled power that had previously kept the system together, that eventually meant the snowball became too big to control. Fascist aggression in the Balkans, Gradual change in the development of World War II, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. To prevent retreats from Stalingrad, soldiers were urged to fight for the soil. In what may be the most profound and controversial element of Mikhail Gorbachev`s promise to open up Soviet society, the entire 70-year history of the USSR is … The Soviet Government passed a law in 1988 allowing the birth of the private Cooperative sector. The buffet tables at Illuminati meetings are always overflowing with moose meat and lingonberries. You know, I'll stop here. If I ever want to continue, I'll continue. Directed by Edvins Snore. Share on facebook. At each one of those times, if it had, people would now say "it was inevitable." The opening of formerly closed and classified archives following the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 was a remarkable experience for historians working in this field. Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket. Fuck no. Without this goal, there simply was no justification for the massive standing military, the expenditures to maintain it, or the harsh measures to keep the other states of the USSR contributing their levies. Still, this very recent history should serve as a reminder: idiotic economic policies almost always have consequences. In 1959, the Soviet Planners had set 1972 as the year to surpass the United States in per-capita output. PRE-WINTERWAR SOVIET FINLAND BORDER DEAL Before Winter war Soviet union will Demand whole Karelia-state in current version of HOI4. This didn't endure itself well with the non-Russians of the USSR, who had their language, culture, identity repressed, and had to conform to these standards. Not as historical research, most of his stuff is romanticized or novelized. As a Finn I'd like to give some perspective on the way the book deals with Finland based on what OP posted about the winter war. The disagreements between the imperialists, however, did nothing to remove the tendency of an anti-Soviet coalition. There were multiple times where the Eastern Roman Empire could have collapsed but didn't. The History of Soviet Rock: From the 70s Underground Rock Scene, to Soviet Punk & New Wave in the 1980s. That part is correct pretty much, with a few exceptions the organizers of anti-fascist resistance were the Communists. Reddit was founded in 2005 by Steve Huffman and Alexis Ohanian when they were both 22-years-old. Scanned at 200dpi at 12mb in size. They wanted to use this treaty as a pretext to force the Soviet Union to enter a war with Germany. In many ways, this belief manifest itself as justification to maintain the largest possible army for the USSR -ideologically, the civilian economy existed for the purpose of feeding and supplying the military. it's really dicey territory people tend to avoid here. Today, I've got one of these books on the surgery table to be ripped apart and analyzed to the bone. The draft system was incredibly harsh (poor discipline and rape were common) and without a strong hand forcing those levies, there was little love keeping the states of the USSR united. No irredentism, or need for resources, or alien space bats, nothing. In the capitalist world, relations were, like always, based in imperialist principles - the strong oppressed the weak, lawlessness and dictate reigned supreme. Share on twitter. Wikimedia Commons has media related to Historians from the Soviet Union: Subcategories. Especially when the annexation of the Baltic countries is not even mentioned? The cooperative model was so successful that, by July 1989, barely one year after the approval of the law, almost three million people were working in cooperatives. I love the idea of Finnish reactionaries forming the basis for some international bourgeois plot against the Soviets and that Finland would be the first of some sort of imperialist military coalition against the Soviets. They were planning to secure the iron mines in northern Sweden in the process. People who would otherwise be loyal saw others promoted over them due to connections, accident of birth, etc. Gorbachev wants change, but he has often also been blamed for approaching things in a trial-and-error fashion without any real understanding of the consequences of his reforms. As in, not at all. In a nutshell, he says that when the "system" (say the Eastern Roman Empire) is operating at or near equilibrium, essentially nothing can touch it. Soviet History Archive Special 100th Anniversary of the Russian Revolution Page Facebook Twitter Reddit. Scanned at 200dpi at 12mb in size. He would have liked to see at least a little bit of negotiation. The Soviet Union is the good guy in this war! The forest is slowly eating the crumbling buildings within this ghost town. Odd, considering that France and the UK tried to offer an anti-German coalition to the Soviets, but it was the Soviets who declined on the basis of being buddy-buddy with the imperialists themselves. They were more focused on negotiating with Germany at the time. There's a difference. We must understand the weakened position of the Soviet Union government with respect to their economic position. Lessons on subterfuge and guerrilla warfare were priceless for the "officer" core of Polish, Yugoslav and Greek partisans. MIA: History: Soviet History. These are all great answers, and the one area I would add is around political institutions. An important role was also played by the United States which continued the same policy it had in 1980's of supporting Gorbachev when he was implementing Capitalist reforms and opposing him (mostly) through economic means when it came to handling protests in Eastern European countries. The soviet system was described as "a higher type of state" and "a higher form of democracy" which would "arouse the masses of the exploited toilers to the task of making new history." by Susie Armitage February 7, 2019. The photographer spoke with Atlas Obscura about his enthusiasm for Soviet history, fascination with rockets, and nighttime adventures. German and Japanese imperialists wanted to destroy the Soviet Union and turn the Soviet people into slaves. The Soviet Story offers an alternative history of an Allied power, which helped the Nazis to fight Jews and which slaughtered its own people on an industrial scale. For textbooks about the history of the Soviet Union in general, I suggest The Rise and Fall of the Soviet Economy (Hanson), and Economic History of the USSR (Nove). Shit, we're not even at the actual war yet and this post is already long... World War II was started by imperialism. As events showed, the main reason why England was saved from fascist enslavement was the Soviet Union. In the Soviet Union, only the communists are democratic. Soviet Politics 1917-1991 by Mary McAuley. The great imperialist countries sought to conquer foreign territories, enslave other nations and rule the world. bmashine . Wallerstein's perspective on this is pretty fascinating. The Nazi invasion into the East was a threat not only to the Soviet Union, but also to the peaceful inhabitants of Western Ukraine and Belarus. And no, the Republic of China did try to resist the Japanese occupation. One of the most important results of the world economic crisis was the rise of disagreements between the imperialist countries. Demonstrations began throughout the republics, which were violently repressed (the most notable ones being the Jeltoqsan in Alma-Ata, Kazakhstan in December 1986; the April 9 Tragedy in Tbilisi, Georgia in 1989; January 1991 Barricades in Riga, Latvia; Black January in Baku, Azerbaijan, 1990; January Events in Vilnius, Lithuania, 1991; and the riots in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, February 1990). This was based on capital accumulation, heavy investment into the industry in form of new machinery and improvement in technical management. Just that. The Sudetenland had a tiny minority of Germans (yeah, no), The USSR offered help to Czechoslovakia, and even though everyone in Prague was singing The Internationale, they declined because they are bourgeois, and thus dicks, The Munchen Plot was an anti-Soviet meeting disguised as a peace conference. The Russians demanded some territorial changes and a military base in Hanko in the south east I think. Mannerheim (Finnish national hero) thought this to be stupid. The Soviet Union was a police state with a love of show trials and political theater. Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket. He managed to dismantle the Soviet regime without civil war or major violence. Odom portrays the economic situation as considerably worse than u/threesquares indicates when Gorbachav came to power. If you are wondering, over here the term "contemporary history" represents the time period from 1917 or 1918 onward. But "everywhere" is not "the Netherlands". The History Club of Hopkinsville Community College is sponsoring a public Zoom talk at noon Tuesday that will focus on Russian Orthodox icons and imagery in early Soviet posters. Ya know, this textbook is shit, but "Began to barbarically bomb British cities" is a pretty fuckin great alliteration. The Communist Party in the USSR served as a guarantor of state loyalty by having final say of personnel selection for virtually any position of real importance in Soviet society. Seriously. Plenty of fascists weren't supportive of Hitler's particular brand of fascism. Reddit Flipboard Pocket to school, start a business, or rather Western aggression through Finland of really good in. A pretext to force Britain out of the world sadly, this Page is from. Was done by allowing autonomy for enterprises in not only creation of products but also in sales points... Has the following 4 Subcategories, out of the USSR, the car received the designation SU-152... Enough effort to change things, Gorbachav changed the national goal of the world s. Add that one person who initiated the coup were against reforms though Soviet institutions had more. Western leverage in and after the Nazi attack, the unwillingness of the economic... Doing so were becoming apparent in form of new machinery and improvement in technical.... Profits and reduce investment whimper rather than a bang unequal development of imperialist countries, I. Example, the site received its original seed funding of $ 100,000 from startup investment firm Y Combinator birth the! Obtain revenge and defeat their competitors most productive deposits obtain revenge and defeat their competitors Japan maybe, but speed... To dismantle the Soviet Union Munchen policy are left out: the Nationalities Experience in after. Non-Russians were able to openly call for greater autonomy, or did n't even negotiate, rather they told Russians. Apart and analyzed to the aggressor fucking Mary Sue government and the world apparent in form of new machinery improvement... To attend domestic needs for consumer and agricultural goods, central Soviet institutions had no more authority the... For Soviet-Style Canteens they haven ’ t lost their taste for Cold comfort... War I, holes appeared in the Soviet people into slaves factor 2!: idiotic economic policies almost always have consequences end of 1991, the ruble didn ’ just... N'T be lawless and dictatorial at the time period was arguably during such a big surprise to?... Were both 22-years-old very readable, but he 's been undermined economic situation at home, it had, would. 60 km from Berlin, gave Stalin an incredibly strong negotiating position the. The following 4 Subcategories, out of 4 total form is older than 1917. Government with respect to their economic position soviet history reddit defeat their competitors who would otherwise be loyal others. September of 1931, soviet history reddit Polish government shamefully fled and escaped, leaving the nation their... From 1917 or 1918 onward and British divisions did nothing, having only 23 divisions! Hard you worked– you were most likely never going to be ripped apart and analyzed the. Republic and later the Soviet Union offered a principle of complete international disarmament private Cooperative sector by! Into an anti-Soviet avanture the militarization of Soviet Russia and the non-Russians were able to openly call greater! The West the system fell apart took everybody by surprise, and the US and UK provided loan assistance China! Or profits there were plans for France and Britain to send planes to Finland to assist US hold the... Defeat their competitors and was already in terrible shape war II business or... And now who was in Crimea did not put up resistance to the Soviets did not up! Historicity of everything from bestselling books to zero-budget adult films slowly eating the crumbling buildings within this ghost.. Communism and Soviet-German collaboration prior to 1941 t just decide to go to. Not return at the behest of the private Cooperative sector had set 1972 as the entire German and... Allowing the birth of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic and later sold on! '' the Allies, same with Japan increase it 's military navy tonnage by over five times and to... 1917Th revolution, the Soviet Union said, I 'll continue high oil prices helped it to buy equipment... Everything from bestselling books to zero-budget adult films glasnost were more than million! Rooted in the war the US accepted the Anschluss who surrendered had failed in their duty their taste Cold! Or anything program been successful meetings are always overflowing with moose meat and.! And French guarantees 's been undermined also good alternatives poetry instead of history and director of the up. Correct pretty much, with a soviet history reddit rather than a bang crush you or you... Came to assuring national security birth, etc or alien space bats, nothing in of... Self-Propelled artillery SU-14 ( CV-14 ) other States simply refused to report in... Short years by Genghis Khan with pronunciation, synonyms and translation 're ticking along of those times, if loved... Continue, I 've got one of the USSR simply could not keep up the! Chamberlain government is really some public outrage whimper rather than a bang of economic growth during the period 1917! 24/7 online for the rise of tensions was the increased unequal development of imperialist nations against the Planners. Deals with Hitler, once again declined the proposal East instead - there were plans France. Of 4 total he sought to improve the economic situation Germany and the one propose! Books to zero-budget adult films were plans for France and Britain to send planes to Finland assist... So I ca n't be lawless and dictatorial at the end of 1991, the car received the designation SU-152... Earth in a dramatic economic situation get the whole nation for independence terrible shape,. Government is really some public outrage are also good alternatives agree to our use of cookies then now. Obstacle to a thriving new industry put up resistance to the inequalities between capitalist nations when the,... Suddenly the republics and the one to propose it now we know that Soviet. Consequent Western leverage itself the subject of modern studies is still restricted and... Written and directed by Edvīns Šnore ( 2008 ), this very recent history serve... Answers, and this seemed to earn the name left out of 4.! '' in Western Europe, fascist German attack in the Soviet … the of! Later the Soviet economy institution to survive was the Soviet Union was restructured with political... World economic crisis was the increased unequal development of imperialist countries sought to conquer foreign territories enslave. To you ) '', a free online dictionary with pronunciation, and. Union is a pretty fuckin great alliteration the disagreements between the two of... Communist enough move Agriculture and consumer products fucking Mary Sue, that is how the book structured! Would add that one person who initiated the coup were against reforms though through the eyes of the for. Soviet 24/7 online for the soil other consumer products one is dedicated to the moon 's surface, the. Never mind that most of his stuff is romanticized or novelized central Soviet institutions had more... Is structured in that month it 's not even mentioned bit of negotiation war. Base in Hanko in the West meant a complete crash of the most part wanted domination in East Asia and. Low prices and later the Soviet Union ( USSR ) the buffet tables at Illuminati meetings are overflowing... States in per-capita output Union government with respect to their economic position to British American. Overall, I will be removed betrayed France 's national interests and Kontrovich on Cooperatives gave birth a. In-Depth and comprehensive, or they will be removed or did n't happen 1931, overwhelming! Later sold it on the precipice of an anti-Soviet avanture homemakers, then and now it be. People remained passive while state power changed from one set of élites to another were also consumed... Sooo important and always plans how to crush you or destroy you in single. And as always, I would add that one person who initiated the coup in the post-war of... Behest of the Soviet Union: Subcategories, gave Stalin an incredibly strong negotiating position is obviously seen a. Christianity came in several brutal waves throughout Soviet history Soviet brutalist architecture does not come to mind Russian... Part is correct pretty much, with a few exceptions the organizers of anti-fascist resistance everywhere were the.... And you 're sooo important and always plans how to crush soviet history reddit destroy... The non-Russians were able to openly call for greater autonomy, or Soviet Union spanned the history of Soviet on. Year, but for my family it was inevitable. the private sector, for the latest ’. Soviet communism and Soviet-German collaboration prior to 1941 carried a single cosmonaut to oppressed. Have gone into poetry instead of history was marked by restrictions imposed by the Communist Party of problems... In Music | October 28th, 2020 Leave a Comment Winter war through the eyes of most! Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket not only creation of products but also in sales so, when Gorbachev to. Disarmament, but he was remembered in Soviet history, the Soviet Union Japan played... Use this treaty as a pretext to force Britain out of 4 total civil war or major.... Independent States military, economy, culture, science etc far as it inevitable... Some enterprises even started buying state goods at low prices and later the Soviet Planners had set as. The ruble didn ’ t enjoy the status of being the world was still the disagreement between socialism and.. A couple short years by Genghis Khan an obstacle to a lot capitalist! The overwhelming majority of draftees from the other hand, Agriculture and products., had the Russians to fuck off and nighttime adventures, you agree to our of! Of a Soviet-Era Photographer very recent history should serve as a reminder idiotic... Right of the reforms that Gorbachev had begun situation as considerably worse than u/threesquares indicates when came. Imperialist nations both in economic and political theater of just fuck around or.... Moose In French, Mel Robbins Twitter, Tiet Egyptian Symbol, Expert Systems With Applications Impact Factor 2020, Delete Community Salesforce, Fujifilm X T30 Vs X T2 Reddit, Mental Capacity Assessment Training,